Mashed Potato Pie


by Nov 12th, 2010 // Holiday, Recipes, Sides

Mashed Potato Pie

Mashed Potato Pie

Why is it that sweet potatoes get all the pie love at Thanksgiving? I’m an equal opportunity potato lover and I really wanted to give some regular old potatoes a chance. I called my friend John, a true gourmand, and talked through the idea. Together we decided I could make this pie just like I would a sweet potato pie but without the added sugar.

Mashed Potato Pie

John suggested I add garlic and some freshly grated good cheddar cheese. Miracle of miracles, I had all the ingredients in the house already so my kid and I got right to work.

Mashed Potato Pie

We undercooked the potatoes ever so slightly before whipping them up with butter, milk and eggs. This gave the pie that country look and an excellent texture. The pie came out even better than we had imagined. It’s going to make a great Thanksgiving side. Before we head over to the recipe, I’m dying to know what you think of the new website?

Mashed Potato Pie Recipe

Thanksgiving Planning: Can be made 1 day ahead and reheated.

Prep Time: 15 mins  Cooking Time: 45 mins to 1 hour

2 to 3 russet potatoes (2 cups mashed)
1/2 stick butter (softened)
2/3 cup milk
2 eggs
1 tablespoon minced garlic
1 cup good shredded cheddar
salt & fresh ground pepper
good pie dough

Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Peel and cut potatoes into chunks and boil for 30 to 40 minutes until tender. Drain and transfer to a mixing bowl. Break apart with a fork. Add butter and garlic. Use a stand mixer to blend together and then add milk. Slowly add eggs while continually beating on medium speed until mixture is mostly smooth. (You’ll want some chunks of potato for texture.) Stir in cheese by hand and add salt and pepper to taste. Pour filling into unbaked pie crust and bake for 45 to 50 minutes or until knife comes out clean. It will come out of the oven puffy but allow it to cool a bit / drop before slicing and serving.

Mashed Potato Pie


46 Comments on “Mashed Potato Pie”

  1. 1.) Rebecca
    November 12th, 2010

    I love pie…I love mashed potatoes…this is the perfect combination. I'm hungry just reading this post. Yum!

  2. 2.) Lisa
    November 12th, 2010

    OMG, I love your new website! The recipe looks absolutely divine! Can't wait to give it a try. I bet all that creamy goodness just melts in your mouth. Yum! Thanks!

  3. 3.) eMJay
    November 12th, 2010

    That looks delicious! My kids love potatoes, but we rarely have mashed ones, maybe I can break our trend with this!

  4. 4.) Dana
    November 12th, 2010

    My 6th grade (oh how the years have flown by since then!) math teacher used to call me potato girl. I can't recall how she knew I LOVE all things potato, but I certainly know that it was the truth. Give me a potato any which way (vegetarian please!) and I will love it. This pie looks great! And your new background is adorable!!

  5. 5.) Vicki
    November 12th, 2010

    Mashed potatoes very well could be my all time favorite good!! :)
    Man – Thanksgiving dinner is my favorite and all these sides are making my mouth water!!! Lol!!

  6. 6.) debbiejl
    November 12th, 2010

    Potatoes cooked anyway is great by me!

  7. 7.) Mee
    November 12th, 2010

    Love the new look of the site, seriously fantastic! Mashed potato pie is pure genius.

  8. 8.) Dana
    November 12th, 2010

    The new site is gorgeous and the little illustrations are maybe the cutest thing I've ever seen. LOVE IT!

  9. 9.) adamzurn
    November 12th, 2010

    I love mashed potatoes and all their creamy goodness. I wonder if I could use this recipe with my Thanksgiving mashed potatoes leftovers. My wife is pretty sold on traditional food prep for the big turkey day.

  10. 10.) Macki
    November 12th, 2010

    The new site is adorable, beautiful and clean! Love it! As for the mashed potato pie, you can never have enough pies at Tday, sweet or savory!

  11. 11.) Michelle
    November 12th, 2010

    This sounds so easy and such a great alternative to the normal sweet potato and marshmallow catastrophe that always shows up on our table!

  12. 12.) Michelle
    November 12th, 2010

    What a great idea!! Must try this one, too! My husband would love this.

  13. 13.) Stevee
    November 12th, 2010


  14. 14.) Jeannette
    November 12th, 2010

    The new site is very pretty! But I miss the sidebar with the most recent posts. :( Anyway, great idea for a new and more interesting way to serve potatoes. Our Thanksgiving dinner is loaded with mashed potatoes and sweet potatoes, so this would be a nice variation!

  15. 15.) Miranda
    November 12th, 2010

    Sounds very delicious. Good for vegetarians too. I'm also fascinated by the other post about letting babies gnaw on food n

  16. 16.) Kali Garofoli
    November 12th, 2010

    cheese + mashed potatoes = love in my mouth!!! I also like your new website design. Follow you every day!

  17. 17.) Megan
    November 12th, 2010

    When I was a kid I hated mashed potatoes…I know it's weird. However, I'm pretty sure if my Mom made it into pie I would have gobbled it right up.

  18. 18.) Anna
    November 12th, 2010

    The site looks great! I only wish the badge at the top were a little bigger. This recipe is perfect; I love all things pie and all things potato – perfect combination.

  19. 19.) Sara
    November 12th, 2010

    This looks delicious! I am from Ireland and of course potatoes are a staple in my house! Thanks for the recipe, will have to try it!!

  20. 20.) Nikki
    November 12th, 2010

    This is such a great idea and a nice change from just regular potatoes! My husband is a "meat and potatoes" kinda guy. So this is going to be a nice addition to our menu!!

  21. 21.) Shay
    November 12th, 2010

    Looks like a homerun to me!

  22. 22.) corinneweitzman
    November 12th, 2010

    Potato pie might be the perfect food. The new website is AMAZING. I love it!

  23. 23.) Mariko
    November 12th, 2010

    The new site is super cool. I think I may like this better than regular pie.

  24. 24.) Nicole
    November 12th, 2010

    potato anything makes me drool. i love how much this is like a quiche but sooooo much easier.

  25. 25.) cimmonz
    November 12th, 2010

    oh yum!! another great way to eat potatoes, garlic and cheese!!! ;D
    thanks for the inspiration!

  26. 26.) tryityoumightlikeit
    November 13th, 2010

    What a great idea! This looks yummy. I love the new design but can I keep the old badge? I like the "I cook with my kid" phrase.

  27. 27.) CookingWithMyKid
    November 13th, 2010

    That badge is temp. Will be putting up a new I COOK WITH MY KID badge next week.

  28. 28.) Heffalump
    November 13th, 2010

    Ooh, this looks good! I'd choose this over sweet potatoes any day!

  29. 29.) CrashTestMonkey
    November 13th, 2010

    Oooh… must try!!! :)

  30. 30.) Ashley
    November 13th, 2010

    I've never really liked mashed potatoes, they are my least favorite side dish, but this makes them look yummy. As for the new look of the site…I liked it better before, but I like my internet stuff as simple as possible.

  31. 31.) paulajakobs
    November 13th, 2010

    This looks so delicious! I can't wait to try it.

  32. 32.) Alison
    November 13th, 2010

    I can't wait to try this one!

  33. 33.) GramaJean
    November 14th, 2010

    Pie looks good.As for site would like a better way to see the latest posts.Like at least the last 2 weeks in a little sidebar, in order not have to hunt for them.

  34. 34.) @HotMessHousWife
    November 14th, 2010

    THis looks pretty tasty, I must admit. Nice site redesign, btw!

  35. 35.) JenG
    November 14th, 2010

    This looks incredible! I can't wait to try it!

  36. 36.) whitney m
    November 15th, 2010

    So unique!! I must try before thanksgiving!!!

  37. 37.) Min
    November 15th, 2010

    What a great idea! Looks delicious!

  38. 38.) Becky
    November 15th, 2010

    I have a whole bag of potatoes that are screaming to be used and soon. This is such a great idea, especially as a base recipe with experimenting with!

  39. 39.) kiersten
    November 15th, 2010

    this looks great – i love potatoes!!

  40. 40.) deebo
    November 16th, 2010

    this is def a neat way to make potatoes!

  41. 41.) Susan
    November 17th, 2010

    I could make this to impress the MIL. She's never seen a potatoe she didn't like!

  42. [...] who commented on the Mashed Potato Pie Post said “I can’t wait to try this one,” was randomly selected as our winner. Thanks [...]

  43. 43.) BrianJ
    July 21st, 2011

    YUmmy!!! I’ve never had regular mashed potato pie, and I really want to try it, this recipe sounds great and the only way I am going to be able to have “mashed potato pie” is if I make it myself. The Recipe looks easy so I gotta do this!!!!!!!

  44. [...] we are serving up for sides this Thanksgiving: Cranberry Sauce Trio, Herbed Crock Pot Stuffing, Mashed Potato Pie, Baked Sweet Potatoes and Apples, Nutty Caramelized Cauliflower, and keep the kids busy decorating [...]

  45. 45.) Pandora Bracelets
    November 27th, 2011

    I have been surfing on-line greater than three hours these days, yet I by no means found any attention-grabbing article like yours. It is pretty price enough for me. In my opinion, if all web owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the web might be a lot more helpful than ever before.

  46. 46.) Condie
    March 28th, 2012

    This is very similar to a mashed potato casserole that has for years been a favorite here. Instead of milk and butter, I use cream cheese. I also use various herbs and onions. Putting it into a whole wheat pie crust will make it a bit more special. I’ll give it a try. :-)

Leave a Reply