Pumpkin Pie French Toast


by Oct 9th, 2010 // Breakfast, Most Popular, Recipes

Pumpkin Pie French Toast

Pumpkin Pie French Toast

Can you see that pumpkin pie layer between the two pieces of french toast? How could I resist making this yum-a-licious breakfast when it is so easy to assemble? Oh, and even though it is totally decadent, I did modify it from traditional baked french toast recipes to make it arguably more healthy. It’s got like 10% less guilt associated with it now.

Pumpkin Pie French Toast

Here’s where it all started: We like to make baked french toast when we’re having company since it can be made in advance and popped in the oven 30 minutes before the guests arrive. We used the same premise but added pumpkin, pumpkin pie spice and maple syrup.

Pumpkin Pie French Toast

My kid got right to work with the maple syrup. He’s no fool. He knows that you can never quite get all of it out of the measuring cup. That’s what fingers are for!

Pumpkin Pie French Toast

The master of the whisk had to do a little extra work to break up that pumpkin, but he made it happen.

Pumpkin Pie French Toast

Can you believe how good those swirls of pumpkin look in there? Oh em ghee. Now for the recipe…

Pumpkin Pie French Toast

Prep Time: 45 to 1 hour  Cooking Time: 30 to 40 mins

5 or 6 thick slices challah
3 eggs + 2 egg whites (alt: 4 eggs)*
1 cup lowfat milk (alt: half and half)*
1/4 cup maple syrup (alt: 1/2 cup maple syrup)*
1 cup 100% pure canned pumpkin
1 tablespoon pumpkin pie spice
powdered sugar for dusting
maple syrup for serving

Cut each slice of challah in half and then in quarters. Set aside. Meanwhile, whisk together eggs, milk, maple syrup, pumpkin and pumpkin pie spice. Spray a 9 inch square baking pan with baking spray and assemble one layer of challah fitting it in like puzzle pieces. Then assemble another layer directly on top of the first. Pieces don’t have to fit perfectly, but it helps if they are all laying flat. Pour the pumpkin mixture over the bread being sure that it seeps into every crevice and covers each piece of bread up top. It will look like you’ve got too much liquid. Don’t worry, as long as it’s not spilling out, you’re ok. Let the bread soak up some of the liquid for 45 minutes while you clean up and then preheat the oven to 350 degrees. Place the baking dish on the middle rack in the oven and cook for 30 to 45 minutes or until the pumpkin is set and bread is brown. Cut into squares and then dust with powdered sugar and drizzle with maple syrup. Makes about 6 servings.

*A few notes: Many baked French toast recipes call for you to let the bread soak over night in the fridge before baking. I was worried this would get too soggy because of the pumpkin addition but you could give it a try. I’d be interested to hear how it turns out. Also, if you want to make a more traditional version of this, use the alt ingredients listed above. I’m certain it will taste spectacular.

Pumpkin Pie French Toast


24 Comments on “Pumpkin Pie French Toast”

  1. 1.) ClairMcL
    October 10th, 2010

    Looks so delicious! How much pumpkin do you use? Thank you for a lovely blog – I really enjoy seeing you cook together.

  2. 2.) CookingWithMyKid
    October 10th, 2010

    Thank you, thank you for pointing that out. I looked at the recipe 5 times thinking I had forgotten something and I couldn't remember the most obvious ingredient.

  3. 3.) CookingWithMyKid
    October 10th, 2010

    It makes 6 servings if you are serving it with other things. Otherwise, I'd make a recipe and a half and bake it in a 9×13 pan.

  4. 4.) @thenewsupermom
    October 10th, 2010

    I'm so sad that I already had breakfast today. Wonder if the family wants this for lunch AND dinner?

  5. 5.) Min
    October 10th, 2010

    Oh this looks good! I made Pumpkin French Toast before slice by slice, I hope I still have the scrap of paper on which I wrote down what ingredients we used! I love making French toast in a pan though, I'm definitely going to try this!

  6. 6.) Nicole
    October 10th, 2010

    spray the measuring cup with pam before pouring in the maple syrup, and it will slide right out easily!

  7. 7.) Steph
    October 10th, 2010

    Oh, that looks really good! Can another type of bread be substituted for challah? Not a big fan of Challah.

  8. 8.) CookingWithMyKid
    October 10th, 2010

    I imagine it would taste great with French bread.

  9. 9.) CookingWithMyKid
    October 10th, 2010

    My family would!

  10. 10.) Mara
    October 10th, 2010

    Another awesome pumpkin recipe – thank you! I tried the pumpkin muffins you posted the other day and they were a hit at my house! Thanks again!

  11. 11.) jack
    October 10th, 2010

    i cannot wait to make this next weekend. cannot wait. can't wait.

  12. 12.) Lisa
    October 12th, 2010

    I made this last night for breakfast-for-dinner and it was delicious. I made 1.5 batches and used a 9×13 as suggested above. It worked perfectly and I plan to enjoy some of the leftovers this morning. Thanks for the fantastic recipe.

  13. 13.) @jessco
    October 16th, 2010

    I made this for brunch today. Wonderful!! Thanks for the recipe.

  14. [...] Pumpkin Pie French Toast from Cooking with my Kid [...]

  15. [...] the recipe at Cooking with my Kid. Maybe the author wants to be friends with Dining at my [...]

  16. 16.) marlene
    October 21st, 2010

    try brioche!

  17. 17.) @tomokrg
    October 23rd, 2010


  18. 18.) Jennifer
    October 31st, 2010

    Yum! It was so fast to put together so despite the baby sleeping in and my inlaws being here, I still got in on the table within an hour or so of waking up. I "one and a halved" the recipe in a 9 x 13, used ciabatta and I didn't let it soak for much more than 15 minutes, opting instead to help along the soaking up process by flipping the bread and pressing it a bit. Took 37 minutes to bake. And it was really, really good and surprisingly very pumpkin pie-like. Much easier and more tasty than the baked French toast I usually make. Thanks so much!

  19. 19.) Rose
    November 5th, 2010

    Yum yum in my tum tum tum, in my tum tum tum, yum, YUM!
    Two thumbs up from my girls!

  20. [...] from: Pumpkin Pie French Toast | Cooking with My Kid: Teaching My Kid … Related Posts:French Toast Recipes We'd Make for Paris Jackson | The Family Kitchen Paris [...]

  21. 21.) Lucy
    November 27th, 2010

    Great recipe! I made it for my family just now!…. or rather, it's soaking for another 20 minutes before I pop it in the oven. I added praline pecans on the top and can't wait to try this. (Also, I didn't have enough challah, so it was a great excuse to get rid of the leftover honey wheat rolls from Thanksgiving dinner.)

  22. [...] Pumpkin Pie French Toast | Cooking with My Kid: Teaching My Kid and myself the art of cooking in 365… (cookingwithmykid.com) [...]

  23. 23.) Claire
    September 8th, 2012

    oh yummy yummy yummy. i think i would use some baguette, though. ya know because of it’s availability

  24. [...] recipe and photos compliments of cookingwithmykid.com [...]

Leave a Reply